China fines Mintz $1.5m for ‘unapproved’ work after raids on Beijing office

Fine against US consultancy firm comes amid growing concerns over China’s openness to foreign investment.

China has fined US firm Mintz Group about $1.5m for doing “unapproved statistical work” after a raid of its Beijing office sparked worries about China’s openness to foreign investment.

The Beijing’s Bureau of Statistics said in a ruling dated July 5, first reported by The Wall Street Journal, that the firm had carried out “foreign-related statistical investigations” without seeking and obtaining approvals.

In a further notice on its website dated July 14, the bureau said Mintz conducted 37 such investigations from March 2019 to July 2022.

As punishment, the bureau confiscated 5.34 million yuan of the firm’s “illegal proceeds” and imposed an administrative penalty of an equivalent amount, resulting in a total fine of about $1.5m.

Mintz has 60 days to file an appeal and six months to file an administrative suit. It did not respond to a request for comment by the Reuters news agency.

The firm has previously said it is licensed to conduct legitimate business in China and that it has always operated lawfully.

As per Mintz’s website, its services include background checks on potential business partners and new hires, fact-gathering for lawsuits and internal investigations.

Chinese authorities raided Mintz’s Beijing office in March and detained all five local staff in what turned out to be the beginning of a sweeping crackdown on consultancy and due diligence firms, including Bain & Company’s office in Shanghai and Capvision Partners.

Foreign business lobbies said the crackdown damages investor confidence in the world’s second-largest economy.

Even as China reopens for business with the world this year after casting off pandemic controls that effectively shut its borders, it has gotten more suspicious of its engagement with the West, in line with a call by President Xi Jinping to place national security over everything else.

Beijing updated an anti-espionage law in July that broadened the definition of spying and banned the transfer of information related to national security.

In recent years, China has amended a host of laws to restrict foreign access to its data, such as requiring data to be stored in Chinese servers and requiring companies with users’ data to undergo a security review before listing shares overseas.